Transformative, Evidence-Based Ideas

  • Home
  • I
  • District-Charter Collaboration

Focus Area:
District-Charter Collaboration

As school choice grows, policymakers and practitioners increasingly seek engagement and cooperation between charter schools and traditional school districts.

CRPE studied these efforts to determine how leaders can overcome the challenges of working across traditionally competitive boundaries. When done well, collective action can lead to tangible results:

For Charter Schools:

  • Improved access to facilities, funding, and student enrollment
  • Reduced political tensions
  • Greater exposure to district expertise
  • Expanded reach and impact beyond school walls

For School Districts:

  • Partnering in the work of ensuring high-quality schools in all neighborhoods
  • Sharing costs, including recruitment and transportation
  • Gaining access to innovative professional development and curriculum

For the Community:

  • More high-quality school options available for students
  • Better services for English language learners and special education students
  • Streamlined school information and enrollment systems

Major Research:

CRPE’s studies on district-charter relationships focused most closely on 23 cities with District-Charter Collaboration Compacts supported by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation. Between 2011 and 2017, under a grant from the Foundation, we regularly interviewed leaders in school districts, charter schools, and support organizations to track progress on these agreements, reported on local political, legal, and financial barriers to collaboration, and facilitated networking and problem-solving between cities. In January 2017 we published our seminal study, Bridging the District-Charter Divide to Help More Students Succeed. In cities with size-able charter school student populations, we concluded that cross-sector policy coordination is a necessity, not a nicety. However, despite the urgent need, cooperation on common issues was too often treated as a time-limited, forced marriage rather than as a sustained effort and long-term relationship. This study built upon our 2013 interim assessment of 16 Compact Cities.

Our work has provided us the opportunity to dive in to specific policies and programs related to collaboration.

Our reports include:

  • How sectors share instructional practices and cooperate on colocated campuses.
  • How charter schools can access facilities owned by districts via state laws and local best practices.
  • How local politics and diverse charter interests shape the work of collaboration.
  • How partnership schools offer a “third-way” governance model for new school options or turning around neighborhood schools.
  • How cooperation with charter schools can help districts in times of declining enrollment.
  • How districts and charter schools created common accountability frameworks and school discipline policies.
  • How boundary spanners cross between sectors and increase knowledge transfer
  • How district and charter schools can create unified enrollment systems and consider policies such as “backfill.”
  • How states can promote cooperation.

Additional Research:

Many of CRPE’s other reports offer examples of district-charter cooperation, including:

  • Stepping Up: Performance outcomes and system reforms in 18 “high-choice” cities
  • Sticking Points: How school districts implemented the portfolio strategy
  • Making School Choice Work: How parents experience public school choice

Four Ways Philadelphia Can Keep Its Schools Moving in the Right Direction as District Prepares to Retake Local Control

The nominating panel charged with selecting candidates for Philadelphia’s new nine-member school board has received its last application. Now, as the district prepares to retake local control of its schools July 1, the panel’s 13...

Integrating Schools in San Antonio: Start With One. An Interview with Mohammed Choudhury

Cities across the country are grappling with persistent school segregation. While some argue that public school choice increases the problem, there are ways that cities can use carefully designed school choice initiatives as a vehicle...

Three Ways Charter Schools Can Make Sure They Recruit, Hire, and Retain the Teachers They Need

Summer vacation may still be months away, but school leaders across the country are already gearing up to hire teachers for the next school year. Many will find themselves in the same predicament they’ve faced...

New CREDO Report Shows System-Level Supports, Turnaround Expertise Critical to School-Level Improvements

CREDO at Stanford University published a new report today, examining the impact and implementation of nonprofit charter management organization (CMO)-led school turnarounds under Louisiana’s Recovery School District (RSD) in New Orleans and Tennessee’s Achievement School...

What Continuous Improvement Networks Should Learn from District-Charter Compacts

The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation recently announced a new focus on supporting networks of middle and high schools. These Networks for School Improvement are intended to support continuous improvement—built on collecting data and testing...

Passing Notes: Learning from Efforts to Share Instructional Practices Across District-Charter Lines

This report examines recent efforts of districts and charter schools to share key instructional practices and offers recommendations for education leaders to move forward.

Proposal: The Future of the Charter School Movement Requires a New Political Strategy

The national charter movement grew because people from diverse perspectives agreed on the need for a new form of public school free of bureaucratic and union constraints. As political scientist Stephen Page observed, the movement...

Clearing the School Choice Fog for Parents

School choice proponents argue that choice creates equitable access to quality schools and results in the shuttering of schools that perform poorly since few families choose them. However, this is based on families having the...

Denver’s Storied Portfolio District Is Starting to Act Like Just Another City School System

Denver Public Schools hosts endless visits from civic and district leaders looking for ways to reinvent public education. It has been a star portfolio district and a leader in charter-district collaboration. Over the course of...

The Unavoidable Politics of Education Reform

In K–12 education, politics is the great equalizer. It has killed initiatives from the right and from the left, from top-down district curriculum mandates to site-based management. Common Core State Standards, test-based accountability, and the...

Skip to content